I've been traveling to Sanibel for over 30 years and Traders is by far the best restaurant on the island. I've had a number of items on the menu and they have all been good but most recently I ordered the blackened sea scallops with the cheese tortellini and I can honestly say it's the best dish I have ever had anywhere at any time. The scallops were huge and cooked perfectly and the sauce was creamy and seasoned in a chipotle sort of way. What I loved is that it wasn't too rich. I highly recommend Traders and it never disappoints.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.