Like many others found ourselves watching the sun setting over the beach without thinking of dinner. (Yes a wonderful beach, shells & worth the fee to get on the island).
Thanks to Trip Advisor read several reviews that were posted. Went to Traders (w/o a reservation as I said). Had to wait 20 minutes so we took in the bar area (&restrooms which were clean etc). Behind the bar area there is a large gift type area from shells, apparel, sculptures, to forgotten necessities). So be aware that the bar area is not atmospheric as you may want.
The hostesses are great, patrons too ( if you talk to strangers). Waitress attentive from drinks, meal itself to desert. Had appertizers of grilled mushrooms (excellent), tomato & mozzarella, crab cakes. Main courses of grouper w/ink ravioli, ravioli stuffed w/crab & chicken francee. All presented well, excellent quality etc. Their desert special of chocolate bread pudding (++ice cream) can be shared!!
Be aware that it's valet parking. Eatery is on main road near causeway.
Glad forvTrAd and this resturant !