Each visit to Sanibel we eat at Jerry's on Periwinkle Way, in the Jerry's Plaza.I recently ate lunch at Jerry's restaurant in December 2012.
I recommend the Seafood Shell, which is a generous portion of seafood salad in a shell shaped dish, with slices of bell pepper,onion, tomato, and black olives and hard boiled egg halves. It was very fresh and tasty.
Service is good with the waitresses- the lady at the front of the restaurant can be rude at times-even changing out drink order and yelling at the waitress-we just laughed! She has had the same attitude for years-
The restaurant is clean and the prices are good. There is an early bird special each evening also.