I have tried Island Cow after living here several years. Some of the reviews about bugs (we live on a barrier island that is environmentally conscious where tourists want the outdoor experience), bugs cannot be avoided but shouldn't show up in an omelette. After 25 years plus I can say restaurants that have THAT BIG a menu do not do anything well. The servers and hostesses act like you are priveledged to be there. It is all about location! Rosie's (old Hungry Heron) Jerry's, or Sanibel Grill in the Cheeburger plaza are better bets. Ask a local. I have NO IDEA why people line up here!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.