We recently visited Sanibel Island and stayed at the Holiday Inn. we were surprised when the woman at reception recommend we not eat at their restaurant Starfish Grill. However, over drinks at the tiki bar a very pleasant bar tender James persuaded us to dine there and insisted we try that nights special, Hogfish. We both had it and it was phenomenal. Easily the best meal of our trip. We enjoyed it so much we came back and ate there three nights. We even saw James again in the dining room and he was able to get the chef to come out and greet us. A truly pleasant experience. we highly recommend eating here and getting the hogfish special.