Spent a week at Sanibel late January 2014. Decided to pick up some takeout. Tried Island BBQ, located in a small mall next to Subway. DO NOT MAKE THE SAME MISTAKE! We pulled in at 5:30 p.m. Ordered a meal for two that included ribs. Told they were out (a BBQ out of ribs at 5:30? Really?). Said they would substitute pulled pork and pulled chicken. Owner comes in while my order is being worked on. Guy behind counter prints cash register summary, and they high five. Screams to me that their principal concern is money, not product quality or service. Got back to resort. No pulled pork. Pulled chicken was awful. Half smoked chicken was edible, but that is the best we can say. We eat BBQ fairly regularly. I smoke on my big green egg. I expect this place to head south in the not too distant future with the poor quality of food and service. Stay away.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.