Stopped in during our first trip to Sanibel and missed the cupcakes as they were already sold out. We turned our attention to the ice cream and the very friendly staff explained the owner's handmade process. We ordered the Fresh banana, toasted coconut and cookies and cream. All were delicious! Since it was Customer Appreciation Day we got a piece Peanut Butter Chocolate of homemade fudge for free which was ridiculously good. Definitely worth the trip. Next time we'll get there earlier for the cupcakes.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.