Though we didn't stay at the Island Inn, we did have Christmas Day dinner there. The food was fairly well presented and tasted moderate to the price, but the service was absolutely pitiful. The waitress did not return to our table at any point after serving our meal. I watched bemusingly as she doted on a much larger party hand and foot while my family waited patiently for dessert and coffee. Despite two complaints to the manager, who offered both times to comp desserts (which we hadn't had and now no longer wanted), she still delayed in returning with our bill. For food that expensive no one should have to tolerate that kind of dissatisfaction. We did not tip.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.