I have been craving Sanibel Crunch ever since my first trip to Pinnochio's in May! It is SO GOOD! All their ice cream looks absolutely delicious, and the animal cracker on top was the perfect signature touch. Make sure you are attentive though - the staff knows how to move through a line and won't wait for you if you're not paying attention! Also, make sure you don't hold the door open. The shop is small, and I'm sure if the Florida heat was constantly let in they would have delicious puddles instead of scoops.
I can't wait to return to Pinnochio's next time I'm on the island!