Decided to chance it for my son's high school graduation party based on numerous excellent reviews. The best cake I've had in 45 years (Italian Rum Cake) and as others have said you'll feel like you just got transported to NY. For me, it was back in time to our local market on Long Island when I was very young back in the '60's. Walk into Mazzaro's and smell. Instant time warp for me. Look around, from the small carts to the meat market, from the cheeses to the bakery, cold cuts to imported canned tomatoes. Everyone was so friendly and helpful & the food so fantastic, maybe it's a good thing Mazzaro's is 65 miles away!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.