There's a lot of pizzerias outside of NY that claim to have New York style pizza, unfortunately, many of them fall short. But the smell wafting out of Brooklyn's bated me to try yet another. I always like to try a plain cheese slice to "authenticate" the veracity of a NY pizza claim. Brooklyn's was delicious! Cheesy, slightly greasey, thinly sauced, on a thin, slightly chewy and crispy, foldable crust, with that authentic New York pizza flavor! I would make another trip to St. Augustine for the sole purpose of eating more of this delicious pizza. Perhaps I'll try their calzones too - they were huge!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.