We recently visited St Augustine and hit town around lunch. We parked at the fort as we planned to visit there after eating. I used the tripadvisor mobile app on the smartphone, checked reviews, and decided on J.P. Henley's a few blocks away.
I love this place. The beer list was great and I tried some new stuff. The service was friendly and helpful. The food was great and the prices were very reasonable for the quality.
I also really liked the atmosphere. The front area is not enormous but it felt just right. Overall, the atmosphere says "pub" but is able to do so while also feeling bright (at least at lunchtime) and clean.
We walked by a number of restaurants on the way to this one and I am glad we didn't stop before we got to JP Henley's.