New to the st. Augustine area we have tried many places to eat in the past 6 months. Casa Benedetto is our favorite find. A quaint A frame with everything we were looking for. The food is absolutely delicious. Brought up Italian with Sicilian background it was like "coming home". Talked at length to the owners the very first visit....where we learned why the food was so good. Only the best ingredients and all made from scratch. From Appetizers to the desert...EVERYTHING is homemade and delicious. Garlic is cut fresh..lemons are squeezed fresh...everything is made to order.!!! Have been back often since our first visit. Have taken company there too. Everyone is made to feel like old friends or family. The owners are hard working, hands on and the most "real" people you will ever meet. You leave not only full and satifsfied but also having a new friend....even the waitresses feel like family by the time you leave.