We visit St. Augustine at 3 to 5 times a year. My husband and I go to Casa Maya at the minimum 3 times during a week's stay. The breakfast is amazing. The apocolypto sandwich and the poblano eggs are usually what we order, with a side of quacomole, it is so good that we don't care it is breakfast. Everything is so fresh. They just opened up their new location across the street which is very large so there won't be as much trouble getting a table anymore. They just started serving dinner and it was another great meal. I had a wrap filled with steak for lunch one day and it was the best wrap I have ever had, no joke. The family who owns Casa Maya are very involved at the restaurant and pleasant. If you have a special request they always try to please you. We always recommend Casa Maya when people ask where to eat. Keep in mind this is not a Mexican restaurant (which is a common misconception) which is why we love it.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.