Spent a week in St Augustine and ate dinner in a different restaurant every night until we found the Casa Maya by chance on the penultimate evening of our holiday. We were so impressed that we returned the next night. The guacamole starter is second to none and the sangria with hibiscus is a must-drink. The choice of main courses includes a variety of salads, different fish and all kinds of meat. All served in imaginative and entirely delicious combinations. Service was friendly and unobtrusive. No intrusive live music either, which put us off so many other restaurants. On top of all this, great value for money.