I've been to Nickel City many times over the last three decades. My ex-wife was from Buffalo NY, and it reminded her of home. Just came back and don't know how to rate this.
The crowd was really rowdy last night. Boisterous to an extreme, and the management didn't discourage it. But it wasn't unpleasant. This is a NY Crowd. Excellent bar food, and everything that is a well known foodie choice for locals to eat to remember that region. Beef on Weck, Wings, and such. The real thing from what I am told. It seems the same after all of these years, but not my favorite choice. Every time I have come here it was with a real New York Buffalo original. This place is not lacking for fans.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.