As I walked in I did not feel I it was 2019 rather 1955. A wonderful throw back to a slower time.The restaurant is part of an inn over looking the water. Walking into the restaurant I thought a sport jacket would have been appropriate. We had a nice round table for our party of six. The service was excellent. The food was to everyone's liking. Given the group size that indicates a variety of tastes.
After the nice meal we walked around the grounds for a pleasant post meal saunter.
There is parking along side the inn part of the Lodge.
I plan to go back.
It is not an inexpensive place, nor is outrageous price.

We had the house salads, the shrimp special and the power greens. Both were very nice. Excellent service. However if you were looking for that great waterfront dining view, this was not the place. We ate on the back screened in deck, which was pleasant enough and you could see the water about 100 yards away. We were looking forward to coming here and were only a bit disappointed with the view.

Wonderful food, service and view. Excellent blue crab and corn chowder, Key lime martinis, shrimp salad, everything was good. Just a few minutes from Alden Pines golf course. Prices are comparable to the rest of the eateries on Pine Island except it’s white table cloths and excellent food and service. Went here for lunch numerous times during our month on the island.

Celebrating anniversary of one couple & it fit the occasion perfect. Our waiter Max M. was great & made us feel very comfortable & special! Always there with bread without having to ask & a smile. We had the scallops & shrimp special, wild red snapper & mussels & shrimp all perfectly presented & delicious. Was a stormy day so didn’t get to check out the walk outside for the sunset. Maybe next time. Great place for a special day or just because. All staff is very professional & friendly. Creme Brûlée was outstanding. Make the journey & experience the Florida adventure.

We visited the Tarpon Lodge with neighbors who were led there by a friend. It's a little out of the way on Pine Island near Cape Cora; in SW Florida. Excellent food and excellent "Old Florida" environment. More than worth the visit. We went for Lunch and the menu ranged from a hamburger to a lovely mushroom ravioli. Good restaurants are at a premium in this area and this one just increased the supply by one.