We've been going to Angelo's since 1993. It's been a family tradition when we go to St. George Island for the Seafood Festival in November and we would make the (almost) one hour drive to eat at Angelo's. BUT since the original restaurant was destroyed by Hurricane Dennis in 2005 this restaurant has become a hit-and-miss mess. The menu has changed so much and is so pricy that we are sometimes at a loss to pick something to eat. We LOVE their Buffalo Backs, but the last five times we've made the hour long drive, we find that they don't have them. Even when we have called ahead to ask!
We stayed on St. George Island in April and decided to give Angelo's one last try for Buffalo Backs; we walked in, asked if they had them before we were seated (this on a Sunday at 12:30) and were told 'no.' We turned and walked out. Angelo's: you are overpriced and underwhelming. We will not be coming back again after 30 years of patronage!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.