We (6 adults) visited the Magic Kingdom on New Years Eve. We made reservations for Tony's Town Square Restaurant back in July! Our reservations were for 6 p.m. and we were seated with only a short wait. Our waiter was attentive considering it was very busy. Five of us ordered the chicken parmesan with spaghetti and it was very good. One ordered just the spaghetti and that also was good. We ordered a cheescake for dessert and it was so cute because they drew a picture of Lady and the Tramp in chocolate on the plate. Right after dinner, we were able to watch the Electric Light parade from the deck of the restaurant. So it all worked out well for us.
The food is a little pricey but worth it to be able to sit down for an hour and relax before heading back out to the crowds.