We stayed 3 nights in May 2010 and I have to say that the Boardwalk is the best choice for me. The rooms are very large and sleep up to 5 people. What I liked most was the location as the hotel is situated between Epcot and Disney's Hollywood Studios, which means that you can easily enjoy the pool in the afternoon and hop back to the parks afterwards (I always bothers me at Walt Disney World, that you cannot walk from your hotel to the parks). It takes 5 minutes to walk to Epcot and 15 to Disney's Hollywood Studios. I also loved the pool which features a great toboggan run.
+ newly refurbished and beautiful rooms with iPhone charger, in walking distance to Epcot and Disney's Hollywood Studios, 1 great family pool with huge toboggan run and 2 quite pools
- no free wireless internet access (10,-$ for wired 24 hours access), no real restaurant in the hotel as they are all located on the BoardwalkMore