Lincoln Road is a place saturated restaurants, most geared to serve turists with average food, and many survive just one season... with few exceptions. La Lupa DI Roma is a family run restaurant that through the years has consistently delivered excellent food and personal, friendly service. They do have a very complete menu and also daily specials, which in my experience have been outstanding. Not sure what to order? Don't be shy and ask any of the family members for a suggestion. Ask them for a wine recommendation too. You may even get a special deal on an excellent "overstocked" Chianti!
Great experience there this New Year's Eve!