Had read good reviews for Island Cafe so gave it a try with another couple.
They close fairly early (last reservation was 8:30) but we found that it was the case for many restaurants on Marco Island.
Nice ambience, quiet and tasteful decor.
Three of us had fish, which was good but not great. We were all excited to try their seafood chowder, only to find out they were all out after we placed our orders.
Service was so-so, but it was late for them and we were one of the last tables. Not bad, but there were better places we enjoyed on Marco.