My husband & I celebrated our anniversary last weekend in Marco Island, & had a wonderful dinner at Island Cafe. My husband had the spinach salad, tournedos of beef & chocolate mousse, while I had the mussels, grouper topped with crabmeat & creme brulee. We both agreed that my dessert was superior, and everything else tasted wonderful. HOWEVER, two of my mussels were mostly closed, & after celebratory cocktails, my thinking cap was not on. I opened & ate them. BIG mistake. I was violently ill thru the entire next day. No, I should not have eaten them, but the restaurant should not have served them either. Bottom line, don't take a chance on the mussels.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.