We are frequent in house diners at Joeys. We decided to order a pizza for delivery last week. - what a disaster! I called earlier than usual sensing that the island was busy and was told that my order would take between an hour and an hour and twenty minutes. No issue from my end since I anticipated the delay. I called back after one and a half hours and was told that my order would go out when the driver returned from other deliveries. I told her that I was concerned that my pizza would be cold and she assured me that it was "sitting on top of the oven" and it would arrive hot. Ya, sure. Another twenty minutes passed and I called back. The driver was just leaving and they assured me that I was first on the list. The pizza arrived like a dried up piece of cardboard. I understand that the island is busy and that this was a Sunday night. I tried to accommodate that when I ordered early. What really infuriated me were the many employees who answered the phone and basically blew me off. I am so angry about their callous and cavalier behavior that it will be pretty close to never when I go back.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.