Wife and I purchased a crab cake sandwich and a pistachio grouper sandwich at Sculley's on June 1st. We primarily stopped here due to the waterfront location. The crab sandwich was excellent. The grouper sandwich smelled fishy, was a dark color (under the pistachio crust) and tasted like non-grouper. I complained to the server and asked her to report my conclusion to the manager on duty, i.e. that this fish was either old or not grouper. I showed her the darkened color, also. She remarked that I had already eaten most of the sandwich, thereby intimating I was only trying to work a discount from them. Actually, we have been married 39 years and we share everything we order. So after 3 bites, I was disgusted with my half, and stopped eating. My wife concurred that this was either a grouper-imposter or bad. Server (Nancy) returned and advised they would take $7.50 off bill (This sandwich was $15.99). No discussion with customer at table by management. Led me to further conclude they were aware this fish was not grouper. I would not ever stop here again, and suggest vacationers use reliable and trusted restaurants.