We (3 of us) ate breakfast and dinner at the Island FIsh Company. The view and food was very good! We all enjoyed our breakfast, which kind of surprised me because the restaurat looks like a lunch and dinner restaurant from the road. We went back for dinner a couple of nights later. My son was dealing with an upset stomach and asked for a side salad when we were first seated, and it came out immediately - even before we ordered drinks or our meal. I had the shellfish lovers pasta, without clams or mussels, and there were still plenty of shrimp and scallops! In fact, I couldn't finish the pasta, Our servers, both times, were very nice and efficient. Unfortunately, we weren't able to enjoy the view, due to blustery weather that required them to put the plastic blinds down, but you could tell that on a nice day it would have been beautiful! We will definitely go back there next time we're in the Keys!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.