While staying at the adjacent Holiday Inn, we decided to give Tarpon Creek a try. We dined with another couple and whenever we come down to the Keys we always look forward to good dining experiences. Tarpon Creek did not disappoint. I had the Lobster Pot Pie which was very good and my husband and good friend both had some type of seafood medley that looked wonderful. They both enjoyed it very much and our last party member had the Yellowtail and was happy with her dish as well. The atmosphere of the restaurant is very nice and the staff very friendly.
I say pleasantly surprised because of some previous reviews. We really enjoy good dining and hate to come out of a restaurant disappointed, and in fact I was trying to talk the group out of coming here. I'm so glad I was talked into it. We also thought the prices were fair as well and they had a nice variety in their menu. Next time when in the Keys, we will certainly come back to the Tarpon Creek Bar & Grill.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.