My husband and I went to Key West the end of September and drove to Marathon. We happened upon this place and were pleasantly surprised. Everything is fresh off the boat. Having never tried Hogfish Snapper, we ordered the sandwich and the platter. I got the platter blackened with yellow rice and plantains; my husband ordered the sandwich. It really was amazing and the flavors were spot on. The staff were very nice and the atmosphere is very basic, but clean. Try the cilantro mayonaisse....it's very good. A lot of food and great prices. Can't beat it! Marguerite G.