Two weeks ago was my fifth time staying at Captain Pip's in the past two years and I look forward to it every time I go. It is not a 5 star hotel but it is a comfortable, clean, friendly little spot, hidden in the Keys, where you can go and enjoy some of the best saltwater fishing in the country.
For the price you cannot beat the fact that you have a nice spot to stay (I always stay in the efficiencies) and a nice center console boat. Add to that the fact that you can cook your own catch in your kitchen or on one of the grills outside, or, if you're too lazy (like I often am) you can bring it over to Porky's and get it in a few different ways.
I've never had a problem with the staff and they are extremely accomdating. For example, this year I ran into problems with Hurrican Irene making it impossible for me to get down there and Barbara worked with me to reschedule and even though it was last minute, I was able to use my deposit towards the rescheduled date. The dockside staff is also very helpfull and full of tips for you. I admit, I have had problems with a boats here and there, but nothing beyond what any boat owner would experience, and the staff always had me back on the water and fishing in no time.
Location, Location, Location. It's right next to the Seven Mile Bridge, so if the weather is a little too windy, you can usually go fishing on the Florida Bay side, but if you want to fish the reef, a trip under the bridge to the reef side is about 5 minutes. Another 20 to the reef, depending on the weather, and then the fishing fun begins.
Like I said, I have stayed there five times now, only for fishing trips. Anywhere from 1-5 of my friends/family with me. I have spent days there where the weather is just totally uncooperative, but the location gives you plenty of other option: bridge fishing, sightseeing, lounging and enjoying cocktails. And Porky's is always a favorite spot for me for eating, drinking, and listening to some great local musicians. The staff there is, without a doubt, the greatest. Somehow they always seem to remember me (I'll credit that to their great memory and not my unforgettable personailty).
Fishing trips are what bring me down there, and if you are new to the area, or want to target a specific species, they offer guides, or full charters for a comparable price to other local charters. I have not taken a charter but have used their guides on occasion and have always learned something and caught plenty of fish. Coming from New Jersey, fishing the Keys is quite different, and I would recommend using a guide if it's your first time down there, or you'll be lost.
The one and only complaint I would have is that I wish the chum and bait prices were cheaper for those staying there. It becomes a bit of pain to have to stock up on some things the day before, or wait until the local shops open in the morning. Other than that, no compaints, and I look forward to visting again. Hopefully soon!
