While I was in Islamorada last week with Florida Sportsman Artist and Illustrator Joe Suroviec Joe and I had the pleasure of eating at Bentley's on three occasions.
The atmosphere was great, the food even better and Rebecca our waitress was absolutely excellent. Peter, the owner personally took the time to talk with us and make sure we were well taken care of. As a matter of fact, the chef even came out and asked us how we likes our food - excellent.
We had Crab stuffed Yellow-tail, stuffed Shrimp and Steak as well - ALL amazing. The salads were accompanied with a cold plate, a cold fork and as fresh as I have ever eaten, also great Lobster Bis.
Bentley's is a must while in Islamorada. The portions are big, the service excellent and the price is very reasonable for those on a budget.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.