Firstly the setting of this restaurant is second to none, there are tables next to the bay where the sun sets, truly lovely. We were recommended this place as one of the best in Islamorada so were surprised when the food was not that great, maybe we had an off night? We had tuna tartare which was a bit mushy, we had lobster which was chewy and mussels which were like warm. On the positive side the crab cakes were lovely. The service was not the usual high standard of the US either. So all in all I think the price you pay for the food is for the sunset rather than the actual food, which is a bit disappointing.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.