We've been visiting the Islamorada area for 6 years and are always searching for a great restaurant. We've found it! Wonderful fresh food, delicious specials. What a delight! The atmosphere is upscale. Love the history behind the property. We drove 7 hours from St. Simons Island, Ga, just so we could eat at the Green Turtle as our first stop on this trip. Well worth it!! Will definately dine there again and again! We did also visit on a night when they were doing a live local radio broadcast and it was very noisy near the bar. I would check the event calandar first if I wanted a quiet dinner. The bar drinks are first rate, not watered down. Great wine selection too.