This was the first time I've had Hogfish and it was excellent, so soft and succulent! I would go back if I lived in Key West. The waitress, can't remember her name, was a little too hyper for my taste. Both time we went while vacationing there she was our waitress, go figure. She was nice and all but seemed a little bit under the influence. It could have been the heat. But all in all it was a good experience and I loved the open space of the restaurant!