We got there early, before sunset, on our walk to Mallory Square from Conch Marina where we are staying aboard our boat. The choices of pizza are amazing and the combination of ingredients wonderful. You can request combination pizzas. My husband and I did 1/2 broccoli and sausage and 1/2 vegetarian (eggplant, zucchini, onions, mushrooms, etc.). Our friends did 1/2 broccoli and sausage and 1/2 everything pizza. We consumed them in rapid order. The only reason I have given this 4 stars and not 5 is that the seating is minimal consisting of 2 small tables for 2 outside and 2 small tables for 2 inside. This is really a take out or delivery place as there really is no place to comfortably eat your pizza. However, don't let that deter you as the pizza is genuinely made with love and there is a wonderful variety to try. They also sell certain pizzas by the slice. We are going back tomorrow to try the gelato, we were just too full to try tonight. Steve did give us small samplers... OMG, it is crazy good. The pistachio, if you like pistachio is over the top. No coloring, just natural pistachios. It is silky smooth... can't wait to return for the gelato now. Best coffee in KW according to Steve, one of the partners, and a super lovely person. He gave us each a small sampler of cappuccino to try. The beans are Italian roast, fresh ground by individual cup. He also has American style coffee if you don't want the Italian bean coffee.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.