We stayed at the Reach three nights on our first visit to the Keys. Because of Valentine's Day, the room rate was very high. Our room, a boutique suite, was quiet, clean, fresh and well laid out. The bed was comfortable and the black out drapes appreciated. Staff people were all friendly and informative. The beach, pool area and exercise room were all fine. Having access to the Casa Marina property was a nice bonus and the location of the hotel made walking everywhere easy. If the room rate had been more in the $250 range, rather than $500, we would have judged it a good value.