Just had dinner here for the third time. Every time I come to Key West, Flaming Buoy is a place that cannot be missed.
Try the Lobster Thermador - it is indulgent, but out of this world delicious.
The owner and the staff are all very friendly. We actually considered sneaking in a second dinner during our trip, but time didn't allow.
If you only do one thing during your entire visit to Key West, it should be eating dinner at this place!