I went to Mr C's after it was recommended to us by the hotel concierge. The guy working there is very nice and gives you a lot of ice cream for one scoop. My dad and I really like the rum raisin, and the chocolate fudge flavors. The place is very clean, and kept cool especially on hot days. The only bad thing is that the place is small, but it doesn't really matter because all you are doing eating ice cream. My family and I liked the ice cream so much that we came back again that day, and the next. I really wish they had one near my house because I would go there everyday during the summer. I highly recommend this ice cream place to any one that is in the keys!