Went for the first time after coming to this area for several years and wished we had come sooner. Loved it. A little higher-priced than PJ's, JD's, Crabby Bills etc, but thought the seafood was much better. Very fresh, very good and friendly, helpful waitstaff. I like the informal but clean, bright and roomy seating compared to the tightness of PJ's and the dark, picnic table seating at Crabby Bill's. Just my opinion.
We had a large group and were accommodated with no problem, but we came early. A line was forming by 6pm. Not a huge place but very comfortable.

So far, this place has been the best food and the best value in the IRB area. Never expected a scallop ceviche so fantastic in a place like this. Lots of little gems like that on the menu. It was busy. The waitress was ditzy but polite. I'd go there again in a second.

Keegan's is our go-to place. We have eaten there too many times to count, and have never ever had a bad meal. It's the first place we take visiting friends, and they also rave about the food. There is indeed a new owner, but he has done a great job of keeping the quality high and the menu the same with awesome specials. You cannot go wrong ordering off the specials board. The fish is expertly prepared. Be forewarned that this is not a tourist trap. It is excellent fresh seafood at a reasonable price in a homey and local atmosphere. We love Keegan's and consider ourselves seafood snobs.

Decided to give this restaurant a try after reading reviews. Keegan's is a diner atmosphere, clean and staff friendly. I had the gumbo soup, very good with a kick to it. I also tried the blackened grouper sandwich and it was excellent, served with homemade coleslaw which was also very good.

Probably a place you'd pass right by without noticing, but we locals love it! GREAT food & the service was quick, quick! Loved the He-Crab Soup, fish spread, and the REAL grouper sandwiches....and the oysters on a 1/2 shell were ice cold, fresh & delicious! Highly recommended for families, too!