In our month in the Keys we ate at Square Grouper six times. Every visit was fantastic. We always ordered the fish special of the day. The fish was fresh, well-prepared and she uses a variety of subtle and unique sauces that don't overpower the fish. And the house side salad is a zesty bowl of goodness. The conch soup is delicious, and one day we tried the zucchini fries - yummy. We enjoyed an awesome tiramisu there, and the bread puddings are scrumptious as well.
The staff is friendly and occasionally a little too relaxed. (But hey, you're in the Keys!)
The only bad thing about this restaurant? They're closed on Sundays. Kaya Island Eats has the views, but does not compare to the food quality and taste at Square Grouper.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.