We spend our winters here in Cape Coral and were excited to hear a new restaurant opened at Tarpon Point. Yesterday I took a guest who was visiting us from NJ for lunch around 1:30 p.m. The restaurant was empty but it was a lovely day so the patio was about 1/2 full. The waiter was gracious and very helpful. Things look good for a nice lunch. We ordered the $13 grouper sandwiches and ice tea. My guest ordered hers without cheese (mentioned on the menu). We waited and waited and the waiter came two times to apologies for the wait. A half hour later our sandwiches arrived. My friend’s sandwich came with the cheese and my sandwich’s edge was icy (must have been waiting next to something frozen). The waiter offered to take both sandwiches back but after a ½ hour wait we decided to just keep the sandwiches. The waiter was disappointed but we told him it was not his fault. After I tested my sandwich with a finger inside and it was warm so I cut off the frozen section and ate the rest which was delicious. But for $42 I would not bring my guests back to this lovely setting and pretty restaurant. I was disappointed and embarrassed. My husband and I will give it another try when we return next season, but I will not bring my friends there or recommend this restaurant. As a matter of fact, my neighbors all asked how it was and we told them or saga.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.