We have visited O'Tooles several times in the past and the food was good (not exceptional) and the place was comfortable. Although they claimed at the time the food was homemade fresh daily I had my doubts but that's just me.
Since then they have re-model, and it has become a very uncomfortable place, and the food has suffered we all had the same dishes we ordered in the past and all indicated it was not as good, my main dish was cold on the outside and hot on the inside (microwave) as was the bread pudding I had for desert. I could tell something was amiss when we entered because the place was almost empty inside which was unusual in the past!
May try again but not anytime soon.