Gatsby's is located a couple of doors down from Figaro's (itself a fine place to eat) and just behind a Walgreen's. Don't let the unassuming indoor/outdoor surroundings fool you; this is absolutely the best pizza I've found in Collier or Lee County. The service is a bit slow because of the small number of ovens, but it's worth the wait. The pizzas come in small and large sizes, and the large really is large; two people can make a meal of it and still have some left to take home. Prices are reasonable by Naples standards, and on a recent Wednesday night visit they threw in a large salad for free. I haven't tried any of the toppings, because the plain cheese pizza leaves nothing to be desired. One caveat: during the season the crowds are so great that it may be close to impossible to get in, but during the summer it's a different story. The best bet is to order ahead, and the pizza should be ready by the time you get there.