Having lived in CT and RI for almost 20 years, I became spoiled by New Haven Pizza. When I moved to FL last year, I was very disappointed by the pizza down here. A couple of days ago, I was searching for a different restaurant on TA, and stumbled on a listing for Nick's. I read the reviews, went to their website, and decided I needed to try their apizza at my earliest convenience. I did get my order to go, so I can't really comment on service, although the bartender who took my order was pleasant.
The pizza itself was very good; burnt on some edges and paper thin. Without a side by side comparison, I can't really be specific on exactly where this pizza fell just a little short of the Wooster Street pizzerias to which they are modeling their's after, but for being almost 1500 miles away from the real deal, this was quite an acceptable substitute.
I will return, although I am about a 35 minute drive from Boca Raton. I used to drive over an hour to get to Wooster Street!
In conclusion, not a perfect copy, but quite good, and far superior to other options in the area.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.