We visited Mystic the last weekend in July (2012) and had to see if it was as good as we'd read. The exterior is plain but don't let that fool you. Inside it was welcoming and the staff made our party of 8 comfortable (not easy with a 1 year old with us.) Food was well prepared, try the pan fried fish with coconut vanilla sauce and dried cherries! The seafood shepherd's pie was also excellent and had a taste of everything under puff pastry (YUM!) Service was prompt for cooking food to order and we didn't mind the slight wait. Bill was reasonable too so all in all a great find, and one I'd recommend to a friend!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.