We were so excited when we saw the Oregano Joe's website: pizza looks amazing, fresh, and crispy and the owners seemed committed to fresh, natural ingredients. We ordered a small pepperoni, a small hot oil, a small margarita and a 12-PC wings. We also ordered a brownie and a chocolate chip cookie. The first problem was the girl who answered the phone. It literally took 15 minutes to place the order. She kept repeating it incorrectly and couldn't seem to comprehend why we wanted to exchange the salami on the hot oil for sausage.
Delivery took approximately an hour, which was fine for a Saturday night, delivery man was pleasant. However, when we saw our order, the ranch dressing was pre-packaged Ken's brand, the cookies and brownie (which we were told were homemade) were definitely not, we had salami AND sausage on our pizza, and the margharita looked vile. Cheese was yellowed and not fresh mozzarella...yuck.
I was hoping for big things from this place but Franco's is still your bet bet for delivery in the area. I guess the wait continues for a truly tasty pizza delivery spot in Milford.