This restaurant lived up to the positive reviews we read prior to going there. Upscale, industrial feel with a bar area. We ordered two pizzas to meet the dietary issues of our diners. The draft and bottle beer selection was broad. We tried a couple of local New York brews and enjoyed them. We had a Neopolitan pizza for the non-cheese lovers and a fresh tomato & basil pizza with added meatballs. Both were delicious- the red sauce is amazing and the crust is hand tossed and tasty. They have wheat crust also. The entrees looked great as they passed our table. This will be a "must visit" spot when we go back to Middletown.