One thing that Guilford was in need of was a local restaurant which serves traditional Italian "comfort" food and reliable, delicious pizza. At long last Guilford has that restaurant- Nick and Tony's.
We frequently go here. We always take out pizza here even though it's ten minutes away from home. Our favorite is their version of Fresh Clams Casino pizza. We came here with relatives and ordered a Clams Casino pizza along with a small shrimp and pesto pizza. They use fresh clams and garnish the pizza with lemon slices- a nice touch. The shrimp and pesto pizza was delicious- rich with homemade pesto flavor and a crisp, thin crust.
We also came here and had dinner on several occasions. Dinner is quite reasonably priced at Nick and Tony's. And it is first rate. One of my favorites is their version of ziti with sausage and broccoli rabe- rich with meaty sausages and broccoli rabe delicately blended in strong tasting olive oil- yum! Also we tried their spaghetti with clams in a red sauce with its home made, rich tasting, well-blended red sauce with a ripe tomato flavor. Shrimp fra diavolo is also a winner here. Bread is always fresh with crisp crust.
Service is warm, friendly, and accommodating. The wine list is adequate and glasses of wine are reasonably priced. Portions are generous, so if you are not all that hungry, you can take some home with you and have it for lunch the next day.
Overall, Nick and Tony's actually sets a high standard for local Italian fare.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.