There is no better pizza in Fairfield County besides Maione's. It's not *really* a sit-down place, even though you can. If you've ever been there on a Friday night for pick-up, though, you'd see it's more than popular locally to forgo the numerous delivery options. All of their specialty pizzas are amazing, but I'm still a fan of the plain cheese, which tells you a lot about the quality of their ingredients and cooking.
Their sandwiches are also great: great bread, fresh ingredients, interesting/non-traditional combinations. French fries are not the best, but it's not Maione's French Fries, so all's forgiven. I'm originally from Philly and think their cheesesteaks are pretty close, (not as greasy, which is actually a good thing) although I wish they had chicken cheesesteak on the menu, as well.
I'm a huge fan of Bleeker St. Pizza in the W. Village (Nonna Maria) and would say Maione's holds up to that standard, which is pretty darn good. So far, it's the best pizza I've encountered in CT.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.