My husband and I visited Secret Stash on a return trip to Crested Butte. Our prior experience in 2012 was so good that all year we talked about coming back and having more pizza. We are not fans of long waits, so we usually try to go to Secret Stash for an early dinner, and find that we arrive and are seated right away if we arrive around 5-5:30. Although that's early for us, by the time our pizza came, it was nearly 6:30, so this is something to keep in mind. Both times we had Frank as our server, he is very friendly and attentive. Both trips we had their garlic bread and Kylena's meatball pie, two of our favorites. Watch out for the plentiful whole garlic cloves on the meatball pie - they are happy to modify if asked. We also enjoyed the Stash Wings (juicy and great taste) and the Mandatory BBQ Chicken pizza this visit - new favorites to add to our list for the next time we return. As other reviewers have said, the atmosphere is very casual and the place gets jammed, so make sure you know that up front and are willing to have this kind of an experience before you go. Highly recommend.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.