We stopped in on a whim last weekend, mostly because Extreme Pizza (though on the north end of town) was close to our car. The "Extreme" name just doesn't fit in any way. We were impressed by the friendliness of the staff. There were a few TV's showing sports and a few pretty laid back patrons. It was a very relaxed vibe.
The pizza itself was not bad in any way, but not particularly outstanding in any way either. Thin crust with a good sauce that was not to sweet, not to spicy but the pie was sparsely topped.
Overall, this is not a bad choice, but Fatty's up the hill a bit has a lot more excitement, a broader menu and some really outstanding pizza. So does Downstairs at Eric's on Main Street. So next time we'll head back to one of those places. They are worth a few extra steps.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.